The short answer
Choose darkness first. Treat everything else as a probability, not a promise.
If you can choose between several nights, favor the evening with less moonlight and a comfortable weather forecast. Puerto Rico’s tourism guidance specifically recommends darker nights because bright moonlight competes with the faint natural flashes.
That does not mean you need to schedule your entire vacation around one exact moon phase. La Parguera is active year-round, and brightness can still change with water conditions. The practical goal is to stack the odds in your favor without pretending nature follows a booking calendar.
When your dates are flexible, pick the darker night. When they are not, book the night that works and keep expectations realistic.

